• Skip to primary navigation
  • Skip to main content
  • Skip to primary sidebar

Soccer Training Solutions

Individual Soccer Training Tips, Soccer Drills, Fitness Tips and More

  • Home
  • About Us
  • Contact
  • Individual Training
  • Our Complete Training System
  • Fitness & Strength
  • Game Tips
  • Nutrition

Offsides

What Would Happen if the Offside Rule Was Abolished?

By Parker & Walsh 19 Comments

Offside_exampleAmerican sports fans sometimes suggest that soccer should do away with the offside rule. The thought is usually that this change would lead to more scoring, and therefore more entertaining games.

But in order to understand the impact this would have on the game of soccer, it’s necessary to understand some key tactical principles that aren’t as obvious to casual observers.

Taking away the offside rule would be catastrophic to what makes today’s game exciting and would have major negative consequences.

Negative Consequences of No Offside in Soccer

Perhaps the most important concept to consider is space. Think about the large size of a soccer field, and how the offside rule serves to keep the different lines (defense, midfield, attack) relatively close together.

If there was no offside, offenses would immediately put a player or two directly in the opposition’s box right near the goal and attempt to feed long balls to those players.

And to counter, defenses would send someone back there to mark the attackers. The back line as a whole, in fact, would need to retreat significantly, because they can’t leave a huge space behind them that an opponent could get a head start running into.

This would result in a nearly empty midfield consisting of huge swaths of space, and a game filled with long balls and a lot of 1v1 battles, with very little of the cohesion, teamwork, and passing that make soccer a challenging and interesting game today. Players would tire more quickly as well.

In today’s game, creating space is an elite skill. Masters like Messi make brilliant unpredictable runs to earn space.

Players must learn to operate in tight spaces, forwards must time their runs in order to get behind the defense, and defenders need to press and drop together with impeccable timing. These tactics would be all but eliminated with the abolition of offside.

The game would start to look like the youth game of World Cup where a mob of players in front of a goalkeeper all try to score.

For additional evidence, look at throw-ins, where there is no offside. If a team has a player with a long throw, the attacking team simply packs the box with numbers in order to have a chance to scrape together a goal.

Smaller Tweaks to the Offside Rule

So hopefully we now see the reasons against taking away the offside rule. But if we dig a little into soccer history, we will learn that although the complete abolition of offside would be catastrophic, smaller tweaks have already been made over the years. There have been two big offside law changes that took place in 1925 and 2005, both of which changed the way soccer is played.

In 1925, the offside law was changed from requiring three defending players between the forward and the goal to just two (Wilson 38).

This change led to increased scoring, according to Wilson: “On the face of it, the amendment was an immediate success, with the average number of goals per game shooting up to 3.69 the following season, but it brought about significant changes in the way the game was played.

The most obvious immediate effect of the change in the offside law was that, as forwards had more room in which to move, the game became stretched and short passing began to give way to longer balls” (38-39).

Another big change in the offside law came in 2005. Starting then, players had to be on the play by touching the ball or making contact with an opponent.

According to Wilson, “it has become increasingly difficult … for teams to play a hard pressing game with a high offside line, and so the effective playing area has been stretched from around 35-40 m to around 55-60 m” (357). So there is more space for players to play in front of the defense.

However, if you want more goals, then you want more space behind the defense, so you would want teams to play an offside trap which allows for well timed runs and passes.

With the rule change, “The offside trap has been rendered ineffective. The figures bear this out. Opta stats show that in 1997-98 there were 7.8 offside per game in the Premier League, after which there was a fairly steady decline to 6.3 in 2005-06. Since the new legislation came into force, there has been a further decline, to 4.8 so far this season.”

The liberation of the offside law from 2005 has teams defending deeper allowing for more space in front for for teams to play soccer.

So, when we step back and take a closer look, we have already had rule changes that are actually in line with some of what American sports fans were asking for.

Finally, to bring things back to American sports, why not take away the illegal formation in NFL football and let anyone be an eligible receiver? We’d see way more touchdowns!

Of course, this wouldn’t work; it would radically change the strategy, remove structure, make the game sloppy, and disadvantage the defense too much. Same with offside.

Works Cited:

Wilson, J. (2013). Inverting the Pyramid: The history of soccer tactics. New York: Nation Books.

Filed Under: Professional Soccer, Team Tactics Tagged With: Offsides, Pro Soccer, Tactics

Primary Sidebar

Get Better at Soccer – Faster!

Get Started Today - Button Orange

About Your Coach – Parker Koester

Parker Koester
I have extensive experience coaching soccer players of all types and can't wait to help you reach your highest level. Read more

Connect With Us

RSSTwitterFacebook

Soccer Tips Newsletter

Sign up for exclusive soccer tips sent to your inbox and a free ebook of our best soccer training content.

Latest Blog Posts

  • 5 Things You Can Learn from Watching Center Midfielders Play
  • How Youth Players Can Get Better By Watching Local High School and College Games
  • True Size and Height: How Big Are Pro Soccer Players, Anyway?
  • Best Practice Drills for Kids Ages 5 and Under
  • Why Every Soccer Player Should Know Tactics
  • Best Ways to Warm Up for Soccer Training or Pre-Game (Solo, Partner, and More)

Recent Comments

  • Scotty on What Would Happen if the Offside Rule Was Abolished?
  • Mike on What Would Happen if the Offside Rule Was Abolished?
  • Booze Baron on What Would Happen if the Offside Rule Was Abolished?
  • Hugh on What Would Happen if the Offside Rule Was Abolished?
  • Tarr on What Would Happen if the Offside Rule Was Abolished?
  • Tarr on What Would Happen if the Offside Rule Was Abolished?
Affiliate Disclosure and Privacy Policy

True Size and Height: How Big Are Pro Soccer Players, Anyway?

· Leave a Comment

Best Practice Drills for Kids Ages 5 and Under

· Leave a Comment

Why Every Soccer Player Should Know Tactics

· Leave a Comment

Best Ways to Warm Up for Soccer Training or Pre-Game (Solo, Partner, and More)

· Leave a Comment

How Much Do Managers Matter? From Tactical Genius to Man Manager

· Leave a Comment

guardiola

Club vs. National Team Tactics: Why They’re So Different

· Leave a Comment

The greatest accomplishment for any soccer player is to win the World Cup for their country. So it may come as a surprise to many to learn that this and other international tournaments aren't where … [Read More...] about Club vs. National Team Tactics: Why They’re So Different

nou-camp-la-liga

Premier League vs. La Liga: Tactics and Style of Play Compared

· Leave a Comment

It's no secret that watching the best professional players in the world can help you improve your own game. But is there a clear-cut best league to choose? The two top candidates that tend to … [Read More...] about Premier League vs. La Liga: Tactics and Style of Play Compared

epl champions

EPL Tactical Trends in 2022-23: What to Watch For

· Leave a Comment

One of the best ways to get better at soccer is to learn from the pros, and with the recent boom in soccer streaming services there are more ways than ever to watch the best leagues from around the … [Read More...] about EPL Tactical Trends in 2022-23: What to Watch For

soccer shin guards

Soccer Shin Guards: How Big Should They Be and What’s the Best Type?

· Leave a Comment

One of the benefits of soccer over certain other sports is that you don't need to wear lots of protective equipment like pads and helmets. There's one safety measure that is well worth it, however, … [Read More...] about Soccer Shin Guards: How Big Should They Be and What’s the Best Type?

soccer tactical analysis

The Problem With Soccer Tactical Analysis

· Leave a Comment

In recent years a particular type of soccer writing has boomed in popularity: the tactical analysis. These pieces aim to tell a story about how a game unfolded using subtle, easy to miss details that, … [Read More...] about The Problem With Soccer Tactical Analysis

  • The 4 Basic Soccer Skills Required To Play: A Beginner’s Guide
  • 7 Best Fitness Trackers For Soccer
  • Youth Soccer Positions Explained
  • Why All Soccer Players Prefer Grass Over Turf
  • What Are The Physical Benefits Of Playing Soccer? Find Out Here!

Copyright © 2025 · Log in